Best Rated Pizza in Bethpage & Farmingdale

Ciminelli's Pizzeria Authentic Italian in Bethpage, NY

Handcrafted pizza, homemade pasta & catering for every occasion. Open every day in Bethpage, Long Island.

Gourmet Pizza

Four pillars of craft pizza, each one a reason to come back.

Artisan Perfection

Hand-stretched dough, 00 flour, wood-fired inspiration. Every pie a canvas, every slice a statement.

Flavor Elevated

Premium toppings, roasted garlic, truffle oil, house-cured meats. Bold combinations, balanced results.

Indulgent Slices

Double cheese, extra sauce, loaded toppings. For when you want the full slice experience, unapologetically.

Luxury at a Crust

Stuffed edges, garlic-butter finish, premium imported cheeses. Worth every single bite.

Catering for Every Occasion

From intimate family dinners to full corporate events, we bring authentic Italian to your table, wherever that is.

  • Formal sit-down dinners with professional wait staff
  • Buffet-style service for larger gatherings
  • Children's menu available for family events
  • Full bar service, on & off premise
Call to Book Catering Catering in Bethpage โ†’

Looking for a Friday night out? Check out our Live Music Fridays, no cover, full bar, great food.

Family-Owned.
Bethpage's Best.

Ciminelli's has been serving authentic homemade Italian food on Long Island for years. Our kitchen runs on tradition. Every sauce, every dough, every plate is made in-house by people who genuinely care.

Professional staff. A menu that earns regulars. Whether you're grabbing a slice at the counter or booking a full dinner party, you're getting the same kitchen.

Our story & Bethpage roots โ†’

Find Us

Address

427 Central Avenue
Bethpage, NY 11714
Get Directions โ†’

Serving Bethpage, Farmingdale, Levittown, Plainview, Hicksville & neighbors across Nassau County.

Hours

Monday โ€“ Sunday 11:00 AM โ€“ 10:00 PM

Open every day. Holiday hours may vary, call ahead to confirm.